With half the year behind us, it is an opportune time to review the past six months and to look ahead to the rest of the year in the world of personal finance. I am pulling out my crystal ball and making some predictions so please feel free to call me out on it at the end of the year. This is also your opportunity to make some bold predictions too so feel free to chime in.
The big news makers. The real estate bubble collapse gathers steam, down goes bank stock prices, up goes oil and food prices. What’s the link in all three? In our collective hubris, we thought could maintain a consumption based economy forever and the market taught us there are limits to cheap credit and turning our entire economy to feed our consumption needs. What is governments reaction to all of this? Sending rebate cheques or proposing tax cuts in elections to fuel more consumption and dismissing any consumption-based taxes (see proposed carbon taxes- no matter how poorly designed the intention is the same: to limit consumption). Yes, it looks like governments are taking out the playbook which states: “the only way to dig ourselves out of a hole is to keep digging deeper.” And here we thought Nixon and Trudeau-esque economic policies of running up massive deficits were gone. Silly me.
The most underplayed story of the year: Petrobras, the Brazilian oil company, announces the discovery of an deep sea oil-field which could be the third largest find in history. The media puts the story in the back-pages opting instead to focus on “sexy” stories like people who could only afford to buy a home with subprime mortgages now complaining they need to be bailed out. This story could go either way: (i) Brazil (the government is the largest single shareholder of Petrobras) becomes an economic power-house, changing the entire geo-political landscape globally since the reserve could put Brazil into a top 10 oil power; or (ii) this could be the biggest fraud in history since there has been scant detail on the discovery, leading many internet discussion boards to question the lack of full disclosure. Considering how much institutional money has flowed into Petrobras this year if, indeed, the skeptics are right, this could be a colossal wipe-out, leading to questions about the entire industry in general.
Here’s to the blogsphere: For picking up that the mutual fund industry is dying a slow and painful death but recognizing that the mutual fund industry is trying to turn the same trick in new clothes by offering exchange-traded funds with outrageous MER. Not all exchange traded funds are created the same. Check the MER’s carefully. Anything over 1% in MER is simply outrageous (actually anything over 0.75% makes me nervous). Canadian Capitalist is only one of many bloggers who have called out the industry on this issue (so sorry, I could not link to you all).
Most depressing research bit. I posted earlier this year that the Securities and Exchange Commission (the U.S. securities regulators) spent less than 0.5% of its budget on investor education. The rest was spent on important matters-regulation, policy-making, enforcement- but not budgetary items that would impact you and me on a day-to-day basis like a good education on personal finance. Sadly, the same seems to be happening in Canada as well as regulators regulate without asking its primary stakeholders, us, what we want. For administrations paid for and meant to serve us, they sure do miss the point. Expect more enforcement and high-profile cases but no focus on investor education for the rest of 2008 and beyond.
Things that make me worry for the rest of 2008: Softening commercial real estate market could be the final sign the real estate market has completely collapsed in the U.S., choking off of credit earlier this year by the banks will start being felt later this year, lame-duck President means no economic leadership and the continuing de-valuation of the American greenback fueling further inflation, lack of a true carbon emission policy will only create further business uncertainty meaning a slow-down in capital expenditures (businesses can work around bad policies but not policy uncertainty).
Predictions…BCE privatization is agreed at for $36.50/share (as I wrote earlier), a U.S. based mid-tier financial services firm goes under, U.S. banks start making massive dividend cuts (hello Bank of America…), a Canadian bank makes a big acquisition down south, governments finally realize its time to come up with an integrated environmental policy, and not a piecemeal one, after oil hits $160/barrel, steel makes a recovery (yes, steel), Apple finally hits a wall, Yahoo! is sold to MS after the Board and managemet is over-thrown, the stories on the death of the suburbs begin to increase, the T.V. show Lost has a confusing season (you notice it alternates good season, bad season?) and everyone remembers again that cash in the pocket is always nicer than a cheap line of credit.
Anyone care to make a predication?
No post tomorrow. Have a great weekend.




July 3rd, 2008 at 9:12 am
Thanks for the mention Thicken. I’m not sure that the fund industry is dying. Far too many are still unaware of how much fees they are paying and for the ones that are wising up, the industry will point out that fund fees are falling (though in reality, it is falling marginally). And, of course, in the grand old tradition of Bay Street, we’ll still be sold on what’s “hot” today. Though, in fairness, as investors, we should also share some blame for creating the demand for these products.
July 3rd, 2008 at 7:13 pm
Very true about death of suburbs. I’m already seeing those stories. If it’s not “real estate values in cottage country are tanking because people don’t want to spend $80 to go there and back every weekend” it’s “that monster home you bought in Milton was a bad idea because now it costs you $15 a day to get to work”
And yes, Lost will be one giant tease.
July 3rd, 2008 at 8:35 pm
[…] Thicken My Wallet’s take on the top personal finance stories of the year so far. […]
July 3rd, 2008 at 10:52 pm
In the immortal words of Chief Wiggum: “No, dig up stupid!”
Predictions… well, I’m guessing right now that oil stocks are not trading as though oil is going to stay in the $140 range for long… the iShares XEG ETF hasn’t gone up as much as oil has. Part of that is probably that some of the companies are not pure producers, and refinery/retail is probably hurting a little. Nonetheless, to my way of thinking there’s some fixed cost to getting the oil out of the ground, so if at $100/barrel they’re making $20 profit, then at $140/barrel the profit would be $60/barrel, increasing more at the top end… So I suppose my prediction is that the oil stocks will continue to do well (and also that oil itself will be above $130/barrel next year as long as Nigeria remains unstable).
Of course, I’m not quite confident enough in that to buy a “full position” in the ETF (partly because I’m afraid I might just be justifying chasing performance), so I just put a little money in the TD energy fund, creating more demand for a fund with a 2.17% MER. D’oh!
July 4th, 2008 at 12:13 pm
Financing group announced deal will go ahead at $42.75, deal closes Dec. 11. But no dividends (and not making up the last two dividends skipped). That dividend is not small either. I’m sure that gets glossed over and the optics of the deal closing at $42.75 is the focus of the news.
July 4th, 2008 at 2:01 pm
Looks like the BCE buyout is happening at full price!
http://www.globeinvestor.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20080704.wbce0704/GIStory/
July 4th, 2008 at 4:18 pm
3 dividend payments = $882,254,640 fyi. This is almost equivalent to a $41.66 deal price if they did pay dividends. In my books, the deal was ‘effectively’ re-priced, albeit only slightly.
July 4th, 2008 at 5:01 pm
Glad to be on the wrong side of that predication.
BCE was pretty vague on the revised deal terms- expect a much leaner BCE going forward but the big thing is that the shareholders got close to what was expected and BCE management leave with some of their reputation intact.